Electric Smoking System
Electric Smoking System Market Segments - by Product Type (Electric Cigarettes, Heat-not-burn Devices, Vaporizers, E-hookahs, Electronic Cigars), Application (Tobacco Smoking Cessation, Recreational Smoking, Medical Smoking, Others), Distribution Channel (Online Stores, Specialty Vape Shops, Convenience Stores, Hypermarkets/Supermarkets, Others), Ingredient Type (Nicotine-based, Non-nicotine-based, Flavor-based, Others), and Region (North America, Europe, Asia Pacific, Latin America, Middle East & Africa) - Global Industry Analysis, Growth, Share, Size, Trends, and Forecast 2025-2035
- Report Preview
- Table Of Content
- Segments
- Methodology
Electric Smoking System Market Outlook
The global electric smoking system market was valued at approximately USD 19.4 billion in 2022 and is projected to grow at a CAGR of around 24.5% from 2025 to 2035. This growth trajectory is primarily driven by rising awareness regarding health risks associated with traditional smoking, increasing adoption of electric smoking devices as smoking alternatives, and the surge in demand for innovative vaping products. Moreover, the growing inclination toward more sophisticated smoking technologies and the expansion of e-commerce platforms provide a significant boost to market growth. Consumer preferences are also shifting towards products that offer customizable experiences, leading to the introduction of varied flavors and forms in the electric smoking segment.
Growth Factor of the Market
One of the notable growth factors contributing to the electric smoking system market is the increasing number of smokers transitioning from traditional cigarettes to electric alternatives. This transition is largely fueled by the perception that electric smoking systems are less harmful and can aid in smoking cessation. Additionally, the rise in disposable income, particularly in emerging markets, has allowed consumers to explore and invest in premium vaping products that offer enhanced features and experiences. Technological advancements are playing a pivotal role as well; manufacturers are constantly innovating to provide products that are user-friendly, portable, and equipped with advanced heating mechanisms. Furthermore, favorable government regulations and campaigns designed to promote smoking cessation are driving the demand for electric smoking devices. Overall, the combination of health-related awareness, technological progress, and evolving consumer habits is significantly impacting the market positively.
Key Highlights of the Market
- The market is witnessing a strong shift towards premium and innovative electric smoking products.
- Online sales channels are gaining traction, accounting for a significant portion of overall sales.
- North America holds the largest market share, driven by high consumer adoption rates.
- Health and wellness trends are driving the demand for non-nicotine-based and flavor-based products.
- Emerging markets in Asia Pacific are exhibiting substantial growth potential due to rising disposable incomes.
By Product Type
Electric Cigarettes:
Electric cigarettes, often referred to as e-cigarettes, are among the most popular products in the electric smoking system market. They are designed to replicate the experience of traditional smoking without the combustion of tobacco, thereby reducing exposure to harmful chemicals. The convenience and ease of use associated with electric cigarettes have made them a preferred choice for smokers looking to transition from traditional cigarettes. As users can enjoy various flavors and nicotine levels, the customization options available further enhance their appeal. The growing trend of social vaping and the availability of compact versions tailored for discreet use also contribute to the rising demand for electric cigarettes.
Heat-not-burn Devices:
Heat-not-burn (HNB) devices represent a significant segment in the electric smoking category, offering a unique alternative to conventional smoking. These devices work by heating tobacco to a temperature that releases nicotine-containing vapor without combustion. This method is promoted as a less harmful alternative compared to traditional smoking, appealing to those looking for reduced-risk options. The increasing awareness of the potential health benefits associated with HNB technology is expected to drive its adoption, especially in markets like Japan and other parts of Asia where these products are gaining traction. Manufacturers are consistently working to improve the user experience, including better flavor profiles and device aesthetics, which enhances their market presence.
Vaporizers:
Vaporizers are another prominent category within the electric smoking system market, catering to both recreational and medical users. These devices utilize advanced technology to heat various substances, including dry herbs and concentrates, allowing users to inhale vapor instead of smoke. The versatility and ability to customize temperature settings make vaporizers appealing to consumers looking for a tailored experience. Additionally, the rising popularity of cannabis products has further propelled the demand for vaporizers, particularly in regions where cannabis is legalized for medical or recreational use. The continued innovation in vaporization technology is likely to sustain the growth of this segment.
E-hookahs:
E-hookahs, also known as electronic hookahs or shisha pens, have gained popularity, particularly among younger consumers. These devices provide an alternative to traditional hookahs, offering a similar social smoking experience with the added benefits of being smoke-free and customizable. E-hookahs are often available in a wide range of flavors, appealing to those who enjoy flavored smoking experiences. The rising trend of social smoking in urban areas, coupled with the increasing preference for portable and easy-to-use devices, has contributed to the growth of the e-hookah market. As consumers increasingly seek out options that enhance social experiences, e-hookahs are positioned to capture a significant share of the market.
Electronic Cigars:
Electronic cigars offer a unique proposition for cigar enthusiasts who are looking for an alternative to traditional cigars. Designed to deliver a similar experience as smoking a conventional cigar, electronic cigars provide the benefit of reduced health risks associated with traditional tobacco consumption. The market for electronic cigars is relatively niche but growing, driven by the increasing trend of vaping among cigar smokers. These devices are often marketed toward consumers who appreciate sophisticated flavor profiles and luxury branding, appealing to a demographic that values both style and health-conscious choices. As lifestyle shifts toward wellness, the electronic cigar segment is anticipated to witness growth.
By Application
Tobacco Smoking Cessation:
The application of electric smoking systems in tobacco smoking cessation is a critical segment of the market. With the rising global awareness of the health risks associated with smoking, many individuals are seeking alternatives to help them quit traditional tobacco. Electric smoking products, such as e-cigarettes and vaporizers, are often marketed as smoking cessation tools, providing users with a way to reduce nicotine intake gradually. Research supports their potential effectiveness, leading to increased interest among smokers looking to transition away from harmful habits. Moreover, public health campaigns and government initiatives advocating for smoking cessation further promote the adoption of these products as viable alternatives.
Recreational Smoking:
Recreational smoking represents a significant application area for electric smoking systems, appealing to consumers who enjoy the social experience of smoking without the associated health risks. Electric smoking devices provide an avenue for users to explore various flavors and customize their smoking experience, thus enhancing the recreational aspect. The growth of the vaping culture, particularly among younger demographics, is a driving force behind this segment, with social media and peer influence playing critical roles in its popularity. The ability to enjoy a diverse range of flavors in a social setting makes electric smoking a preferred choice for many recreational users.
Medical Smoking:
Medical smoking applications are emerging as a noteworthy segment within the electric smoking system market. With the increasing legalization of medical cannabis in various regions, electric smoking devices such as vaporizers are being explored for their therapeutic benefits. These products are often utilized by patients seeking relief from chronic pain, anxiety, and other health conditions. The precise temperature control offered by vaporizers allows for efficient delivery of active ingredients, making them an appealing option for medical users. As research continues to validate the therapeutic efficacy of vaporization, the medical application of electric smoking systems is expected to grow significantly.
Others:
The "Others" category within the application segment encapsulates various niche uses of electric smoking systems that do not fall under the main applications mentioned earlier. This may include uses for aromatherapy, social gatherings, and as lifestyle products among enthusiasts. As consumer interests evolve, additional applications may continue to emerge, further diversifying the market. The ability to adapt electric smoking systems for various lifestyles and preferences indicates the potential for growth in this segment, especially as trends shift toward personalization and unique experiences. This adaptability could be a defining factor in the future of electric smoking systems.
By Distribution Channel
Online Stores:
Online stores have emerged as a dominant distribution channel within the electric smoking system market, providing consumers with convenient access to a wide variety of products. The growth of e-commerce has made it easier for consumers to explore different brands, products, and flavors without the constraints of physical store locations. Online retailers often offer competitive pricing, exclusive deals, and user reviews, making the online shopping experience attractive to consumers. As more people become comfortable with purchasing smoking-related products online, this distribution channel is expected to continue expanding, particularly among younger consumers who are more inclined to shop digitally.
Specialty Vape Shops:
Specialty vape shops serve as another critical distribution channel, catering specifically to enthusiasts and users seeking a wide range of electric smoking products and accessories. These shops often provide a curated selection of high-quality devices and flavors, complemented by knowledgeable staff who can guide customers in making informed choices. The community aspect of specialty vape shops fosters a culture of engagement among users, often organizing events and tastings. As vaping culture continues to grow, these shops are likely to remain a popular destination for consumers looking to explore new products and connect with like-minded individuals.
Convenience Stores:
Convenience stores are increasingly stocking electric smoking products, making them easily accessible for consumers looking for quick purchases. The convenience factor appeals particularly to those who prefer spontaneous buying or who may not have access to specialty shops or online platforms. This distribution channel is gaining traction due to the rising demand for portable and on-the-go smoking solutions. The presence of electric smoking systems in convenience stores expands the consumer base and allows users to purchase products in a casual setting, thereby contributing to the overall growth of the market.
Hypermarkets/Supermarkets:
Hypermarkets and supermarkets are beginning to allocate shelf space for electric smoking systems, reflecting the increasing mainstream acceptance of these products. The presence of electric smoking devices in such large retail spaces exposes them to a broader audience, including consumers who may not actively seek out these products. The convenience of one-stop shopping allows consumers to buy electric smoking devices alongside other groceries and daily necessities. As retailers recognize the profitability of stocking electric smoking products, the market is likely to benefit from increased visibility and availability in hypermarkets and supermarkets.
Others:
The "Others" category in the distribution channel segment includes various unconventional sales channels such as pop-up shops, events, and social media marketplaces. These channels often target niche audiences and provide unique shopping experiences that draw in consumers looking for something different. For instance, pop-up shops at festivals or events allow brands to create an immersive experience, while social media marketplaces cater to the growing trend of online communities sharing and discussing electric smoking products. As the market continues to evolve, these alternative distribution channels may play a more prominent role in reaching diverse consumer segments.
By Ingredient Type
Nicotine-based:
Nicotine-based products are the most common ingredient type in the electric smoking system market, appealing to traditional smokers who seek to replicate their regular smoking experience. E-liquids and cartridges containing nicotine allow users to control their nicotine intake while enjoying the flavors they prefer. This segment is particularly crucial for smoking cessation efforts, as it provides users with an opportunity to reduce their nicotine consumption gradually. As regulations around nicotine content continue to evolve, manufacturers are focusing on creating products that cater to different nicotine strengths, thereby meeting diverse consumer preferences.
Non-nicotine-based:
Non-nicotine-based products are gaining traction as health-conscious consumers seek alternatives that eliminate nicotine altogether. These products cater to individuals who enjoy the act of smoking or vaping without the addictive properties of nicotine. Offering a range of flavors, non-nicotine-based options appeal to consumers looking for enjoyable smoking experiences without the health risks associated with traditional tobacco. The gradual increase in public health awareness is driving the demand for non-nicotine-based products, positioning them as a significant segment within the electric smoking system market.
Flavor-based:
Flavor-based products stand out as a key ingredient type, attracting consumers with the promise of diverse and innovative flavor options. From traditional tobacco flavors to fruity and dessert-inspired concoctions, the variety in flavor profiles enhances the overall smoking experience. The popularity of flavor-based e-liquids has generated significant interest, particularly among younger demographics who are drawn to unique and exciting flavors. This segment is characterized by continuous innovation, with manufacturers regularly introducing limited-edition flavors and seasonal offerings to keep consumer interest high. As the market evolves, flavor-based products are expected to play an increasingly vital role in consumer choices.
Others:
The "Others" category for ingredient types includes products that do not fit neatly into the aforementioned categories, such as herbal blends or organic ingredients. These products cater to niche markets who prioritize natural or alternative ingredients in their smoking experience. As consumer preferences shift toward sustainability and health-conscious choices, this segment is likely to gain momentum. Brands focusing on organic or herbal ingredients are appealing to consumers looking for premium options that align with their lifestyle choices. This diversification within ingredient types contributes to the overall growth of the electric smoking system market.
By Region
The electric smoking system market shows significant regional variations, with North America dominating the global landscape. In 2022, North America accounted for approximately 45% of the total market share, driven primarily by high consumer adoption rates and a well-established vaping culture. The United States, in particular, is a major contributor to this market segment, with a projected CAGR of 25% from 2025 to 2035. The country's extensive distribution networks and consumer awareness regarding smoking cessation options have fueled growth. However, regulatory changes and public health campaigns may influence future trends and consumer behaviors in this region.
Europe stands as the second-largest market, comprising about 30% of the global electric smoking system market in 2022. The region's growth is primarily driven by increasing health awareness and the rising popularity of vaping as a smoking alternative. Countries such as the United Kingdom and Germany are leading the charge in electric smoking adoption, supported by a growing number of specialty vape shops and an expanding online retail presence. As European regulations evolve to accommodate innovative smoking alternatives, the market is expected to experience steady growth, further solidifying its position in the global landscape.
Opportunities
The electric smoking system market presents several opportunities for growth, particularly as consumer preferences shift towards healthier alternatives to traditional smoking. One notable opportunity lies in product innovation, as manufacturers can create new devices with advanced features that enhance the user experience. For instance, integrating smart technology into electric smoking devices could open up avenues for customization and personalization, appealing to tech-savvy consumers. Additionally, the growing trend of health-consciousness among consumers presents an opportunity for brands to develop and market non-nicotine and flavor-based products that cater to the demand for safer alternatives. As public health initiatives increasingly support smoking cessation efforts, companies that align their offerings with these trends stand to benefit significantly.
Another promising opportunity arises from the expanding e-commerce landscape, which allows electric smoking brands to reach a broader audience beyond traditional retail channels. As online shopping continues to grow in popularity, manufacturers can leverage digital marketing strategies to engage consumers directly, build brand loyalty, and offer exclusive promotions. Regional markets such as Asia Pacific are emerging rapidly, with increasing disposable incomes and a younger demographic, creating a fertile ground for growth. Companies that establish an early presence in these markets can capitalize on the rising interest in electric smoking products. The combination of innovation, targeted marketing, and strategic regional expansion presents significant opportunities for players in the electric smoking system market.
Threats
Despite the positive growth outlook, the electric smoking system market faces several threats that could hinder its progress. One of the primary concerns is the increasing regulatory scrutiny surrounding e-cigarettes and vaping products. Governments across various regions are implementing stricter regulations regarding product safety, advertising, and age restrictions, which could create barriers to entry for new players and impact existing companies. This heightened regulatory environment may also lead to increased compliance costs for manufacturers, potentially affecting pricing strategies and profit margins. Additionally, adverse publicity surrounding vaping-related health issues can sway consumer perceptions, leading to decreased demand for electric smoking products.
Another significant threat comes from the competitive landscape, as the electric smoking system market becomes saturated with numerous brands and products. The influx of new entrants may lead to price wars and reduced profit margins, challenging established companies to differentiate themselves through innovation and marketing. Moreover, the potential for negative consumer sentiment based on health concerns or misinformation can pose risks to brand reputations, making it essential for companies to invest in transparency and education. To navigate these threats successfully, market participants must remain agile, responsive to changing regulations, and committed to maintaining product quality and consumer trust.
Competitor Outlook
- Juul Labs, Inc.
- British American Tobacco (BAT)
- Philip Morris International Inc.
- Reynolds American Inc. (RAI)
- Altria Group, Inc.
- Vapor Corp.
- Innokin Technology
- GeekVape
- Smok Technology
- Vaporesso
- Fuma
- Joyetech
- eLeaf
- Relx Technology
- Vype (BAT)
The competitive landscape in the electric smoking system market is characterized by a mix of established tobacco companies and innovative startups, all vying for market share in a rapidly evolving industry. Major players such as Juul Labs, British American Tobacco, and Philip Morris International have invested heavily in research and development to enhance their product offerings and address changing consumer preferences. These companies are leveraging their extensive distribution networks and brand recognition to maintain a competitive edge while also exploring partnerships and acquisitions to expand their portfolios. The competitive dynamics are further fueled by the emergence of various e-commerce platforms, enabling both established brands and new entrants to reach a broader audience and engage with consumers more directly.
In addition to the larger players, several smaller companies in the electric smoking segment have gained traction by focusing on niche markets and unique product offerings. Brands like Innokin Technology and GeekVape have carved out a space in the market by emphasizing customization, user experience, and innovation. These companies often cater to the vaping community, promoting their devices through social media and community engagement. The landscape is characterized by continuous innovation, with product launches featuring advanced technology, various flavors, and user-friendly designs. As competition intensifies, companies must remain adaptable, investing in marketing strategies and product development to retain consumer interest.
Furthermore, regional players are also increasingly making their mark, particularly in growing markets such as Asia Pacific and Latin America. Companies like Relx Technology are focusing on meeting local consumer preferences, navigating regulatory environments, and establishing brand loyalty. As the electric smoking system market evolves, collaboration between companies, whether through partnerships or technology-sharing agreements, is expected to become more prevalent. This collaborative approach can yield benefits such as access to new distribution channels, shared research efforts, and enhanced product offerings, ultimately driving the entire industry's growth.
1 Appendix
- 1.1 List of Tables
- 1.2 List of Figures
2 Introduction
- 2.1 Market Definition
- 2.2 Scope of the Report
- 2.3 Study Assumptions
- 2.4 Base Currency & Forecast Periods
3 Market Dynamics
- 3.1 Market Growth Factors
- 3.2 Economic & Global Events
- 3.3 Innovation Trends
- 3.4 Supply Chain Analysis
4 Consumer Behavior
- 4.1 Market Trends
- 4.2 Pricing Analysis
- 4.3 Buyer Insights
5 Key Player Profiles
- 5.1 Fuma
- 5.1.1 Business Overview
- 5.1.2 Products & Services
- 5.1.3 Financials
- 5.1.4 Recent Developments
- 5.1.5 SWOT Analysis
- 5.2 eLeaf
- 5.2.1 Business Overview
- 5.2.2 Products & Services
- 5.2.3 Financials
- 5.2.4 Recent Developments
- 5.2.5 SWOT Analysis
- 5.3 GeekVape
- 5.3.1 Business Overview
- 5.3.2 Products & Services
- 5.3.3 Financials
- 5.3.4 Recent Developments
- 5.3.5 SWOT Analysis
- 5.4 Joyetech
- 5.4.1 Business Overview
- 5.4.2 Products & Services
- 5.4.3 Financials
- 5.4.4 Recent Developments
- 5.4.5 SWOT Analysis
- 5.5 Vaporesso
- 5.5.1 Business Overview
- 5.5.2 Products & Services
- 5.5.3 Financials
- 5.5.4 Recent Developments
- 5.5.5 SWOT Analysis
- 5.6 Vype (BAT)
- 5.6.1 Business Overview
- 5.6.2 Products & Services
- 5.6.3 Financials
- 5.6.4 Recent Developments
- 5.6.5 SWOT Analysis
- 5.7 Vapor Corp.
- 5.7.1 Business Overview
- 5.7.2 Products & Services
- 5.7.3 Financials
- 5.7.4 Recent Developments
- 5.7.5 SWOT Analysis
- 5.8 Juul Labs, Inc.
- 5.8.1 Business Overview
- 5.8.2 Products & Services
- 5.8.3 Financials
- 5.8.4 Recent Developments
- 5.8.5 SWOT Analysis
- 5.9 Relx Technology
- 5.9.1 Business Overview
- 5.9.2 Products & Services
- 5.9.3 Financials
- 5.9.4 Recent Developments
- 5.9.5 SWOT Analysis
- 5.10 Smok Technology
- 5.10.1 Business Overview
- 5.10.2 Products & Services
- 5.10.3 Financials
- 5.10.4 Recent Developments
- 5.10.5 SWOT Analysis
- 5.11 Altria Group, Inc.
- 5.11.1 Business Overview
- 5.11.2 Products & Services
- 5.11.3 Financials
- 5.11.4 Recent Developments
- 5.11.5 SWOT Analysis
- 5.12 Innokin Technology
- 5.12.1 Business Overview
- 5.12.2 Products & Services
- 5.12.3 Financials
- 5.12.4 Recent Developments
- 5.12.5 SWOT Analysis
- 5.13 Reynolds American Inc. (RAI)
- 5.13.1 Business Overview
- 5.13.2 Products & Services
- 5.13.3 Financials
- 5.13.4 Recent Developments
- 5.13.5 SWOT Analysis
- 5.14 British American Tobacco (BAT)
- 5.14.1 Business Overview
- 5.14.2 Products & Services
- 5.14.3 Financials
- 5.14.4 Recent Developments
- 5.14.5 SWOT Analysis
- 5.15 Philip Morris International Inc.
- 5.15.1 Business Overview
- 5.15.2 Products & Services
- 5.15.3 Financials
- 5.15.4 Recent Developments
- 5.15.5 SWOT Analysis
- 5.1 Fuma
6 Market Segmentation
- 6.1 Electric Smoking System Market, By Application
- 6.1.1 Tobacco Smoking Cessation
- 6.1.2 Recreational Smoking
- 6.1.3 Medical Smoking
- 6.1.4 Others
- 6.2 Electric Smoking System Market, By Product Type
- 6.2.1 Electric Cigarettes
- 6.2.2 Heat-not-burn Devices
- 6.2.3 Vaporizers
- 6.2.4 E-hookahs
- 6.2.5 Electronic Cigars
- 6.3 Electric Smoking System Market, By Ingredient Type
- 6.3.1 Nicotine-based
- 6.3.2 Non-nicotine-based
- 6.3.3 Flavor-based
- 6.3.4 Others
- 6.4 Electric Smoking System Market, By Distribution Channel
- 6.4.1 Online Stores
- 6.4.2 Specialty Vape Shops
- 6.4.3 Convenience Stores
- 6.4.4 Hypermarkets/Supermarkets
- 6.4.5 Others
- 6.1 Electric Smoking System Market, By Application
7 Competitive Analysis
- 7.1 Key Player Comparison
- 7.2 Market Share Analysis
- 7.3 Investment Trends
- 7.4 SWOT Analysis
8 Research Methodology
- 8.1 Analysis Design
- 8.2 Research Phases
- 8.3 Study Timeline
9 Future Market Outlook
- 9.1 Growth Forecast
- 9.2 Market Evolution
10 Geographical Overview
- 10.1 Europe - Market Analysis
- 10.1.1 By Country
- 10.1.1.1 UK
- 10.1.1.2 France
- 10.1.1.3 Germany
- 10.1.1.4 Spain
- 10.1.1.5 Italy
- 10.1.1 By Country
- 10.2 Asia Pacific - Market Analysis
- 10.2.1 By Country
- 10.2.1.1 India
- 10.2.1.2 China
- 10.2.1.3 Japan
- 10.2.1.4 South Korea
- 10.2.1 By Country
- 10.3 Latin America - Market Analysis
- 10.3.1 By Country
- 10.3.1.1 Brazil
- 10.3.1.2 Argentina
- 10.3.1.3 Mexico
- 10.3.1 By Country
- 10.4 North America - Market Analysis
- 10.4.1 By Country
- 10.4.1.1 USA
- 10.4.1.2 Canada
- 10.4.1 By Country
- 10.5 Middle East & Africa - Market Analysis
- 10.5.1 By Country
- 10.5.1.1 Middle East
- 10.5.1.2 Africa
- 10.5.1 By Country
- 10.6 Electric Smoking System Market by Region
- 10.1 Europe - Market Analysis
11 Global Economic Factors
- 11.1 Inflation Impact
- 11.2 Trade Policies
12 Technology & Innovation
- 12.1 Emerging Technologies
- 12.2 AI & Digital Trends
- 12.3 Patent Research
13 Investment & Market Growth
- 13.1 Funding Trends
- 13.2 Future Market Projections
14 Market Overview & Key Insights
- 14.1 Executive Summary
- 14.2 Key Trends
- 14.3 Market Challenges
- 14.4 Regulatory Landscape
Segments Analyzed in the Report
The global Electric Smoking System market is categorized based on
By Product Type
- Electric Cigarettes
- Heat-not-burn Devices
- Vaporizers
- E-hookahs
- Electronic Cigars
By Application
- Tobacco Smoking Cessation
- Recreational Smoking
- Medical Smoking
- Others
By Distribution Channel
- Online Stores
- Specialty Vape Shops
- Convenience Stores
- Hypermarkets/Supermarkets
- Others
By Ingredient Type
- Nicotine-based
- Non-nicotine-based
- Flavor-based
- Others
By Region
- North America
- Europe
- Asia Pacific
- Latin America
- Middle East & Africa
Key Players
- Juul Labs, Inc.
- British American Tobacco (BAT)
- Philip Morris International Inc.
- Reynolds American Inc. (RAI)
- Altria Group, Inc.
- Vapor Corp.
- Innokin Technology
- GeekVape
- Smok Technology
- Vaporesso
- Fuma
- Joyetech
- eLeaf
- Relx Technology
- Vype (BAT)
- Publish Date : Jan 21 ,2025
- Report ID : CO-23504
- No. Of Pages : 100
- Format : |
- Ratings : 4.5 (110 Reviews)